Fog Project Documentation (FOG Docs)

Bringing Your Own CA

Properties3
descriptionHow to replace FOG's own Web or Secure Boot certificates with a CA or key you supply, per zone
tagsreference, security, certificates, pki, secure-boot
aliasesBringing Your Own CA, Bring Your Own CA

7 min read

Permalink

Edit this page · View source

FOG 1.6

The Web zone options on this page (--web-ca-*) work the same on FOG 1.5. The Secure Boot zone is where the lines diverge: 1.6’s --secureboot-ca-cert (a genuine CA replacement) has no 1.5 equivalent — 1.5 can only take a flat leaf. See the 1.5 version of this page for what that means in practice.

Bringing your own CA

FOG generates its own certificates by default, but each zone described in FOG’s Certificate Zones can be replaced independently with a CA or key you already run. This page is the reference for doing that; see the PKI glossary if a term here is unfamiliar.

Version support

--secureboot-ca-cert is a FOG 1.6 addition; on earlier releases only bringing your own Secure Boot signing leaf (not a CA) is available — see Secure Boot zone below for what that means in practice.

--web-ca-cert/--web-ca-key/--web-ca-root are available on both the 1.6 and 1.5 lines. Update your installer before using them; the 1.5 line only gained them recently.

Web zone

./installfog.sh --web-ca-cert /etc/pki/web-int.pem \
                --web-ca-key  /etc/pki/web-int.key \
                --web-ca-root /etc/pki/root.pem

--external-ca/--ca-cert/--ca-key/--ca-root predate this and target the Web zone specifically — that’s what they’ve always effectively meant. Whether they remain a separate mechanism alongside the flags above, or get folded into them, isn’t settled yet; treat --web-ca-* as the current recommended form. For the fog-client certificate-pinning implications of replacing the Web zone’s CA, the ACME/Let’s Encrypt recipe, and troubleshooting, see External CA & Let’s Encrypt certificates — this page only covers the mechanism, that page covers the workflow around it.

Secure Boot zone

./installfog.sh --secureboot-ca-cert /etc/pki/sb-int.pem \
                --secure-boot-key    /etc/pki/sb-leaf.key \
                --secure-boot-cert   /etc/pki/sb-leaf.pem

--secureboot-ca-cert (FOG 1.6) is what makes this a genuine CA-plus-leaf replacement, the same shape as FOG’s own auto-generated pair. Without it, --secure-boot-key/--secure-boot-cert on their own hand the installer a leaf with no CA above it, and that certificate becomes both the signer and the thing you enroll — the flat model, same as before the CA/leaf split existed for FOG’s own key. Rotating a flat key later means re-enrolling every machine — see Rotating or removing a key.

Generating a leaf yourself

If you already have a signing key — a site CA, or one shared with other tooling — pass it and the installer will never touch or overwrite it:

mkdir -p /root/fog-secureboot && cd /root/fog-secureboot
 
openssl req -new -x509 -newkey rsa:2048 \
  -keyout MOK.priv -outform DER -out MOK.der \
  -days 3650 -subj "/CN=FOG imaging - $(hostname -f)/" \
  -nodes
 
# The same certificate in PEM. Both formats are needed -- see the note below.
openssl x509 -inform DER -in MOK.der -outform PEM -out MOK.pem
 
chmod 600 MOK.priv
cd /path/to/fogproject/bin
./installfog.sh \
  --secure-boot-key  /root/fog-secureboot/MOK.priv \
  --secure-boot-cert /root/fog-secureboot/MOK.der
  • MOK.priv — the private key. Never leaves this machine. Back it up somewhere you would put a root password, not somewhere you would put a config file.
  • MOK.der — the public certificate, DER-encoded. This is what you distribute to clients and what mokutil enrolls; it is not sensitive.
  • MOK.pem — the same certificate, PEM-encoded. This is what sbsign and sbverify read.

Both paths are recorded in .fogsettings, so later upgrades keep using them without the flags being passed again. The two options are only meaningful together — the installer refuses half a pair rather than leaving kernels unsigned on a server whose admin believes they are signed.

sbsign and sbverify cannot read a DER certificate

They load certificates with OpenSSL’s PEM_read_bio_X509, which rejects DER outright:

$ sbsign --key MOK.priv --cert MOK.der --output out.efi in.efi
Can't load certificate from file 'MOK.der'
error:0480006C:PEM routines:get_name:no start line ... Expecting: CERTIFICATE

mokutil and MokManager want the opposite. Neither tool tells you which format it wanted, so keep both files and use MOK.der for enrollment and MOK.pem for signing. The installer’s --secure-boot-cert accepts either and converts internally, so this only bites you when running sbsign/sbverify by hand.

The -days 3650 gives ten years. Choose something you will actually remember to renew — an expired MOK stops machines booting. FOG’s own auto-generated CA uses a longer lifetime, on the logic that a CA is meant to sit still for years while the leaf underneath it does the rotating.

Use a descriptive CN

It is shown in MokManager when someone enrolls it, and again years later when someone is trying to work out what that key is for. FOG imaging - fog.example.edu beats MOK.

Getting the CA/leaf split by hand, without --secureboot-ca-cert

Nothing above requires your key to be self-signed. If your organization already runs an internal CA (AD Certificate Services or similar) and can issue a code-signing certificate, --secure-boot-key/--secure-boot-cert (or --sign-key/--sign-cert in fos/build.sh) accept that leaf certificate and its key exactly the same way — enroll that same leaf as the MOK and nothing else changes. Standard code-signing templates do not carry the Module-signing-only OID below, so this does not run into that trap.

A CA can do more than substitute for the leaf, if you want it to. shim does not just exact-match the enrolled certificate — it validates the embedded PKCS#7 signature’s certificate chain against whatever is enrolled (sbsign --cert <leaf> --addcert <intermediate> is what embeds that chain). That means enrolling your CA’s root or intermediate once, then signing with any leaf issued under it afterward: reissue or rotate the leaf and no machine needs to be touched again — the same benefit FOG’s own auto-generated key already gets automatically. Without --secureboot-ca-cert, doing this with your own CA means signing and publishing by hand: follow signing the FOS kernels with --addcert added to the sbsign call, and enroll the CA’s certificate rather than a leaf.

One thing this does not get you: a way to skip enrollment entirely by piggybacking on infrastructure your fleet might already have. There is no generic Intune/GPO mechanism to push an arbitrary org CA into UEFI db — what exists there is only Microsoft’s own certificate rollover. If your CA is not already enrolled fleet-wide by some other means (vendor BIOS tooling, or manual Setup Mode), the one-time-per-machine visit still applies — it just becomes permanent once done.

Nor does any of this extend to HTTPS. Kernel/shim trust and iPXE’s TLS root store are two unrelated mechanisms — enrolling a CA here changes nothing about which HTTPS servers a Secure Boot client will fetch from. See HTTPS and netboot.

Generate a fresh key — do not reuse the MOK you already have

If this machine has ever built a DKMS module, it already has a MOK, and it is tempting to reuse it. It will not work.

Since shim 15.4 (Ubuntu 21.04 and later), keys carrying the Module-signing only KeyUsage OID 1.3.6.1.4.1.2312.16.1.2 are deliberately ignored by both shim and GRUB when validating something to boot — they are only good for signing kernel modules. Ubuntu’s and Debian’s automatically generated DKMS MOK carries exactly that OID.

The failure is a plain Security Policy Violation at boot with the key showing up quite happily in mokutil --list-enrolled, which is a memorably unhelpful combination. The openssl req command above produces a key without the OID, so just use it.

The key FOG generates carries no such OID either, so this only applies if you are supplying your own.

Client Communication zone — not replaceable this way

The Client Communication zone (.srvprivate.key/.srvpublic.crt) is deliberately not replaceable by bringing your own CA. It’s anchored at the certificate every fog-client has already pinned, so replacing it means re-deploying trust to every registered machine by some other means (GPO, client reinstall) — there’s no built-in path for it, because there’s no way to do it without touching every endpoint. See Client Communication keypair.

pathlen:0 CAs

If your CA carries pathlen:0 — an ordinary thing for an enterprise to issue — it can’t anchor an intermediate. The installer detects this, says so, signs the web certificate directly from it instead, and leaves Secure Boot on its self-signed key. Nothing is silently broken.

See also

Graph View

Backlinks